Is Bitcoin stupid? Do the Math like I did…

I Spent 10 Years Calling Bitcoin Stupid. Then I Actually Did the Math

My uncle bought Bitcoin in 2013 for something like $120 a coin. He sold it two years later at what he still calls a “huge profit” $340.

He tells this story at literally every family dinner, usually somewhere between the turkey and the pie, and for a decade I just nodded and privately filed the whole thing under “stuff my uncle is wrong about.”

I thought Bitcoin was a casino. Internet Monopoly money for people who watch too many YouTube thumbnails with red arrows pointing up.

Then last spring, mostly because I was procrastinating on an actual work deadline, I read the original whitepaper instead of just having opinions about it secondhand like a normal person. Nine pages. Twenty minutes, tops. And I finished it kind of annoyed not because it was convincing, but because it didn’t match either version I’d been fed. Not the “future of money, get rich or die trying” version the Twitter bros sell. Not the “obvious scam, it’s tulip mania” version my more cynical friends keep repeating at me like it’s a mic drop.

It’s weirder than both. And honestly more boring than either camp wants it to be, which weirdly is what made me trust it a little more.

So here’s the stuff nobody bothered explaining to me properly, in the order I wish I’d learned it.

Image Generated by Chatgpt

Nobody Built This to Make You Rich

This part gets skipped constantly. Bitcoin showed up in October 2008, right as banks were falling over and people were watching their homes get repossessed, written by someone (or a small group, nobody actually knows) hiding behind the name Satoshi Nakamoto. No founder photo. No LinkedIn. No TED Talk. Nothing.

The original pitch wasn’t “invest in this.” It read more like a complaint with code stapled to it: money nobody’s central bank could quietly water down, that no single institution could freeze because it didn’t like what you did with it.

There are exactly 21 million of them. Ever. Not “21 million for now, subject to review.” Not “21 million unless the board votes otherwise next quarter.” That number is the whole argument, honestly — every debate you’ve seen about Bitcoin online eventually traces back to that one stubborn rule.

Compare that to the twenty dollar bill in your wallet right now. The Fed can, and regularly does, create more of those whenever they think the economy needs a nudge. That’s not some shadowy conspiracy — it’s their actual job description. Bitcoin exists as a kind of built-in argument against that whole idea.

The “Bitcoin Is Dead” Headline Is Basically a Genre Now

There’s an actual running tally online of how many times big outlets have declared Bitcoin dead — last time I looked it had crossed 470 since 2010. Forbes has done it. The Guardian’s done it. A hundred finance blogs you’ve never heard of have done it, some of them multiple times, apparently without checking their own archives.

I used to think that was funny in a “look at these delusional crypto people” way. Now I think it says a lot more about the obituary writers than it does about Bitcoin.

Here’s the bit that scepticism, for most of my adult life , tends to skip: Bitcoin isn’t a company you can sue, and there’s no CEO to fire, because neither exists. It runs on tens of thousands of computers sitting in basements, garages, and data centres, spread across pretty much every country you could name. Actually killing it would mean shutting down the internet everywhere, all at once, permanently. Go ahead and try scheduling that meeting.

Okay, Fine, the Price Swings Are Genuinely Annoying

I’ll give the sceptics this one, because it’s true watching something drop 30% in a week feels bad, no matter how many charts you’ve studied. My stomach still drops a little when I check the price after not looking for a month.

But almost nobody mentions the scale problem, and it matters. Bitcoin’s whole market is still small next to something like gold or the S&P 500. When a market’s that size, it doesn’t take a huge amount of money moving in or out to send the price flying in either direction. Picture a canoe versus a container ship in choppy water the canoe isn’t broken; it’s just smaller, so every wave hits it harder.

Has it calmed down any as bigger players pension funds, a handful of companies, even a couple of governments started holding some? A little. Slowly. I’m not going to pretend it’s suddenly boring and stable, because it isn’t.

This Is the Bit That Actually Changed My Mind

Okay, real talk this is where my thinking actually shifted, and it’s the part almost nobody leads with. Bitcoin isn’t really a tech story. It’s a trust story wearing a tech costume.

Most of us have built our entire financial lives around trusting institutions banks, central banks, whoever happens to be in charge to not mess with our money too badly. And to be fair, for a lot of people in a lot of places, that trust has mostly held up fine. But go ask someone who lived through Venezuela’s currency collapse, or Lebanon’s, or Argentina’s several rounds of it, how well that trust panned out. Their savings just evaporated. Not because they gambled it away because someone else controlled the printing press and used it a little too enthusiastically.

Strip away the hype and Bitcoin’s actual pitch is: you don’t have to trust anyone else with this. For someone living through hyperinflation, that’s not a fun side investment. That’s closer to a life raft.

For those of us lucky enough to live somewhere with a relatively stable currency, it’s a much smaller deal more like an insurance policy you’re hoping to never actually need.

So, Should You Actually Buy Some?

Not answering that one for you, sorry. Anybody online who answers that question with total confidence is usually about to sell you a course, and I’d rather not be that person.

What I will say: know what you’re actually buying before you buy it. This isn’t a stock. No dividends land in your account, no earnings calls, no company behind it shipping a product you can judge on its merits. It’s scarce digital money that a growing pile of strangers around the world have collectively decided is worth something — which, if you sit with that for a second, is basically how gold works too. Or paper money, come to think of it. Value has always just been a shared agreement people keep showing up to honour.

If you do dip a toe in, do the boring, responsible version — money you’re genuinely fine not touching for years, a small slice next to everything else you already own, and not because some stranger on the internet told you to (hi, again).

Where I Ended Up

My uncle still insists he made a great call back in 2013. Honestly, even with the sale that looks kind of silly in hindsight now, I’m not totally sure he’s wrong. Bitcoin isn’t magic, and it isn’t a scam. It’s a genuinely strange kind of asset that keeps dragging an old question back into the room — who do you actually trust with your money, people, or code that couldn’t care less about your feelings?

I don’t have a tidy answer for that. I just stopped pretending the question was dumb.

And when you arrive at your conclusion, you will note it is not only bitcoin but a myriad of other tokens in the crypto realm. A few are outstanding, which offer something bitcoin doesn’t: privacy, even anonymity! Look up Z-Cash (ZEC), privacy is optional, or Monero (XMR), privacy is built-in and enforced! To trade Monero without KYC, on DEX, p2p you need to use a tool called   dawnswap.com, it offers all this at lowest entry levels and very decent costs, payment options are other cyrptos (swap them for xmr) or even mailed-in fiat like USD or EUR

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *